Assessing climate model software quality: a defect density analysis of three models

Pipitone, J.; Easterbrook, S.

doi:10.5194/gmd-5-1009-2012

Articles | Volume 5, issue 4

https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-5-1009-2012

© Author(s) 2012. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-5-1009-2012

© Author(s) 2012. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

Articles | Volume 5, issue 4

Development and technical paper

|

09 Aug 2012

Development and technical paper |

| 09 Aug 2012

Assessing climate model software quality: a defect density analysis of three models

J. Pipitone and S. Easterbrook

Viewed

Total article views: 8,737 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)

HTML	PDF	XML	Total	BibTeX	EndNote
5,575	2,823	339	8,737	313	317

HTML: 5,575
PDF: 2,823
XML: 339
Total: 8,737
BibTeX: 313
EndNote: 317

Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013, article published on 15 Feb 2012)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Feb 2013	44	47	1	92
Mar 2013	21	61	7	89
Apr 2013	13	54	2	69
May 2013	27	37	3	67
Jun 2013	17	31	0	48
Jul 2013	16	56	2	74
Aug 2013	15	21	2	38
Sep 2013	23	23	5	51
Oct 2013	15	19	2	36
Nov 2013	12	21	2	35
Dec 2013	56	16	7	79
Jan 2014	27	25	7	59
Feb 2014	23	33	10	66
Mar 2014	23	45	6	74
Apr 2014	27	26	3	56
May 2014	104	53	1	158
Jun 2014	133	30	0	163
Jul 2014	65	42	1	108
Aug 2014	75	45	4	124
Sep 2014	85	55	4	144
Oct 2014	160	100	2	262
Nov 2014	80	70	2	152
Dec 2014	65	42	2	109
Jan 2015	35	39	0	74
Feb 2015	44	13	1	58
Mar 2015	36	18	1	55
Apr 2015	63	18	4	85
May 2015	40	23	2	65
Jun 2015	64	15	0	79
Jul 2015	59	11	0	70
Aug 2015	53	34	0	87
Sep 2015	35	22	1	58
Oct 2015	36	30	2	68
Nov 2015	41	18	0	59
Dec 2015	36	20	0	56
Jan 2016	73	29	1	103
Feb 2016	52	31	1	84
Mar 2016	52	26	2	80
Apr 2016	49	18	1	68
May 2016	45	22	6	73
Jun 2016	43	22	7	72
Jul 2016	38	11	3	52
Aug 2016	41	30	1	72
Sep 2016	48	22	3	73
Oct 2016	36	12	0	48
Nov 2016	30	16	2	48
Dec 2016	20	10	4	34
Jan 2017	42	19	4	65
Feb 2017	38	11	7	56
Mar 2017	98	29	12	139
Apr 2017	66	26	11	103
May 2017	58	19	14	91
Jun 2017	42	19	10	71
Jul 2017	33	12	1	46
Aug 2017	22	11	0	33
Sep 2017	20	11	4	35
Oct 2017	19	16	1	36
Nov 2017	23	11	0	34
Dec 2017	18	13	0	31
Jan 2018	28	8	6	42
Feb 2018	47	10	18	75
Mar 2018	16	9	0	25
Apr 2018	24	13	0	37
May 2018	19	15	0	34
Jun 2018	14	10	0	24
Jul 2018	28	16	0	44
Aug 2018	24	13	1	38
Sep 2018	41	26	1	68
Oct 2018	26	7	2	35
Nov 2018	22	10	2	34
Dec 2018	13	10	0	23
Jan 2019	10	9	1	20
Feb 2019	15	5	0	20
Mar 2019	8	11	1	20
Apr 2019	11	9	1	21
May 2019	17	6	1	24
Jun 2019	9	13	0	22
Jul 2019	21	8	0	29
Aug 2019	15	7	1	23
Sep 2019	3	9	0	12
Oct 2019	21	6	0	27
Nov 2019	12	9	0	21
Dec 2019	21	14	2	37
Jan 2020	20	3	2	25
Feb 2020	17	15	2	34
Mar 2020	28	15	1	44
Apr 2020	30	12	0	42
May 2020	37	4	1	42
Jun 2020	13	7	1	21
Jul 2020	91	44	37	172
Aug 2020	9	6	3	18
Sep 2020	11	14	0	25
Oct 2020	11	7	0	18
Nov 2020	14	8	1	23
Dec 2020	21	9	0	30
Jan 2021	32	8	0	40
Feb 2021	20	12	0	32
Mar 2021	19	8	0	27
Apr 2021	6	12	1	19
May 2021	11	7	0	18
Jun 2021	19	10	2	31
Jul 2021	23	12	0	35
Aug 2021	20	15	0	35
Sep 2021	14	14	0	28
Oct 2021	11	28	1	40
Nov 2021	21	19	1	41
Dec 2021	15	13	0	28
Jan 2022	48	11	1	60
Feb 2022	102	10	1	113
Mar 2022	59	10	0	69
Apr 2022	76	5	0	81
May 2022	70	10	1	81
Jun 2022	66	5	2	73
Jul 2022	65	2	2	69
Aug 2022	70	10	0	80
Sep 2022	53	11	2	66
Oct 2022	43	3	0	46
Nov 2022	51	9	0	60
Dec 2022	50	9	2	61
Jan 2023	33	15	2	50
Feb 2023	53	6	0	59
Mar 2023	50	8	1	59
Apr 2023	33	9	0	42
May 2023	33	9	0	42
Jun 2023	39	6	2	47
Jul 2023	42	3	1	46
Aug 2023	41	5	2	48
Sep 2023	38	6	0	44
Oct 2023	37	13	0	50
Nov 2023	29	5	0	34
Dec 2023	50	15	2	67
Jan 2024	44	13	1	58
Feb 2024	36	14	2	52
Mar 2024	37	12	3	52
Apr 2024	45	9	4	58
May 2024	17	10	3	30
Jun 2024	19	15	6	40
Jul 2024	15	7	1	23
Aug 2024	30	5	1	36
Sep 2024	6	10	0	16
Oct 2024	32	20	0	52
Nov 2024	26	18	2	46
Dec 2024	32	22	2	56
Jan 2025	20	10	6	36
Feb 2025	33	14	5	52
Mar 2025	22	15	0	37
Apr 2025	24	17	1	42
May 2025	28	11	1	40
Jun 2025	44	22	1	67
Jul 2025	31	59	3	93
Aug 2025	42	45	0	87
Sep 2025	18	30	1	49
Oct 2025	37	15	1	53
Nov 2025	51	20	3	74
Dec 2025	3	1	0	4

Cumulative views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013, article published on 15 Feb 2012)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Feb 2013	44	47	1	92
Mar 2013	21	61	7	89
Apr 2013	13	54	2	69
May 2013	27	37	3	67
Jun 2013	17	31	0	48
Jul 2013	16	56	2	74
Aug 2013	15	21	2	38
Sep 2013	23	23	5	51
Oct 2013	15	19	2	36
Nov 2013	12	21	2	35
Dec 2013	56	16	7	79
Jan 2014	27	25	7	59
Feb 2014	23	33	10	66
Mar 2014	23	45	6	74
Apr 2014	27	26	3	56
May 2014	104	53	1	158
Jun 2014	133	30	0	163
Jul 2014	65	42	1	108
Aug 2014	75	45	4	124
Sep 2014	85	55	4	144
Oct 2014	160	100	2	262
Nov 2014	80	70	2	152
Dec 2014	65	42	2	109
Jan 2015	35	39	0	74
Feb 2015	44	13	1	58
Mar 2015	36	18	1	55
Apr 2015	63	18	4	85
May 2015	40	23	2	65
Jun 2015	64	15	0	79
Jul 2015	59	11	0	70
Aug 2015	53	34	0	87
Sep 2015	35	22	1	58
Oct 2015	36	30	2	68
Nov 2015	41	18	0	59
Dec 2015	36	20	0	56
Jan 2016	73	29	1	103
Feb 2016	52	31	1	84
Mar 2016	52	26	2	80
Apr 2016	49	18	1	68
May 2016	45	22	6	73
Jun 2016	43	22	7	72
Jul 2016	38	11	3	52
Aug 2016	41	30	1	72
Sep 2016	48	22	3	73
Oct 2016	36	12	0	48
Nov 2016	30	16	2	48
Dec 2016	20	10	4	34
Jan 2017	42	19	4	65
Feb 2017	38	11	7	56
Mar 2017	98	29	12	139
Apr 2017	66	26	11	103
May 2017	58	19	14	91
Jun 2017	42	19	10	71
Jul 2017	33	12	1	46
Aug 2017	22	11	0	33
Sep 2017	20	11	4	35
Oct 2017	19	16	1	36
Nov 2017	23	11	0	34
Dec 2017	18	13	0	31
Jan 2018	28	8	6	42
Feb 2018	47	10	18	75
Mar 2018	16	9	0	25
Apr 2018	24	13	0	37
May 2018	19	15	0	34
Jun 2018	14	10	0	24
Jul 2018	28	16	0	44
Aug 2018	24	13	1	38
Sep 2018	41	26	1	68
Oct 2018	26	7	2	35
Nov 2018	22	10	2	34
Dec 2018	13	10	0	23
Jan 2019	10	9	1	20
Feb 2019	15	5	0	20
Mar 2019	8	11	1	20
Apr 2019	11	9	1	21
May 2019	17	6	1	24
Jun 2019	9	13	0	22
Jul 2019	21	8	0	29
Aug 2019	15	7	1	23
Sep 2019	3	9	0	12
Oct 2019	21	6	0	27
Nov 2019	12	9	0	21
Dec 2019	21	14	2	37
Jan 2020	20	3	2	25
Feb 2020	17	15	2	34
Mar 2020	28	15	1	44
Apr 2020	30	12	0	42
May 2020	37	4	1	42
Jun 2020	13	7	1	21
Jul 2020	91	44	37	172
Aug 2020	9	6	3	18
Sep 2020	11	14	0	25
Oct 2020	11	7	0	18
Nov 2020	14	8	1	23
Dec 2020	21	9	0	30
Jan 2021	32	8	0	40
Feb 2021	20	12	0	32
Mar 2021	19	8	0	27
Apr 2021	6	12	1	19
May 2021	11	7	0	18
Jun 2021	19	10	2	31
Jul 2021	23	12	0	35
Aug 2021	20	15	0	35
Sep 2021	14	14	0	28
Oct 2021	11	28	1	40
Nov 2021	21	19	1	41
Dec 2021	15	13	0	28
Jan 2022	48	11	1	60
Feb 2022	102	10	1	113
Mar 2022	59	10	0	69
Apr 2022	76	5	0	81
May 2022	70	10	1	81
Jun 2022	66	5	2	73
Jul 2022	65	2	2	69
Aug 2022	70	10	0	80
Sep 2022	53	11	2	66
Oct 2022	43	3	0	46
Nov 2022	51	9	0	60
Dec 2022	50	9	2	61
Jan 2023	33	15	2	50
Feb 2023	53	6	0	59
Mar 2023	50	8	1	59
Apr 2023	33	9	0	42
May 2023	33	9	0	42
Jun 2023	39	6	2	47
Jul 2023	42	3	1	46
Aug 2023	41	5	2	48
Sep 2023	38	6	0	44
Oct 2023	37	13	0	50
Nov 2023	29	5	0	34
Dec 2023	50	15	2	67
Jan 2024	44	13	1	58
Feb 2024	36	14	2	52
Mar 2024	37	12	3	52
Apr 2024	45	9	4	58
May 2024	17	10	3	30
Jun 2024	19	15	6	40
Jul 2024	15	7	1	23
Aug 2024	30	5	1	36
Sep 2024	6	10	0	16
Oct 2024	32	20	0	52
Nov 2024	26	18	2	46
Dec 2024	32	22	2	56
Jan 2025	20	10	6	36
Feb 2025	33	14	5	52
Mar 2025	22	15	0	37
Apr 2025	24	17	1	42
May 2025	28	11	1	40
Jun 2025	44	22	1	67
Jul 2025	31	59	3	93
Aug 2025	42	45	0	87
Sep 2025	18	30	1	49
Oct 2025	37	15	1	53
Nov 2025	51	20	3	74
Dec 2025	3	1	0	4

Latest update: 03 Dec 2025