Dear Authors

I appreciate that the various contributions to the repository now appear in a more unified manner.
Nevertheless, two issues should be resolved before I will accept the manuscript for publication.
It seems that my initial comments prior to the publication of the discussion paper have not been paid attention to. Please check!
1.
Repositories are evolving over time and new diagnostics may be added. Hence the overview page https://github.com/tsussi/cfmip-diagnostics-code-repository will probably change over time. To help future readers of the GMD article, it is mandatory to include a section where everyone will be able to access the code versions used in this paper and which will keep pointing to those versions, even in a few years from now.
2.Section 2 of the manuscript reads like an invitation to add their codes to the repository.
This should not be main purpose of this section. Instead you should describe the current status of the repository and give instructions on how to use it currently (and in the future, see above)
As a side remark it is certainly legitimate to highlight that the repository is not a closed circle.

Best wishes,
Simon Unterstrasser

Dear authors

I acknowledge the efforts of each researcher who contributed to this repository and I hope many fellow researchers will make use of the various diagnostics codes.

Congratulations!
Best wishes,
Simon Unterstrasser