Submitted as: model evaluation paper
|
28 May 2013
Submitted as: model evaluation paper |
|
28 May 2013
Status : this preprint was under review for the journal GMD. A revision for further review has not been submitted.
Test of validity of a dynamic soil carbon model using data from leaf litter decomposition in a West African tropical forest
G. H. S. Guendehou , J. Liski , M. Tuomi , M. Moudachirou , B. Sinsin , and R. Mäkipää
We evaluated the applicability of the dynamic soil carbon model Yasso07 in tropical conditions in West Africa by simulating the litter decomposition process using as required input into the model litter mass, litter quality, temperature and precipitation collected during a litterbag experiment. The experiment was conducted over a six-month period on leaf litter of five dominant tree species, namely Afzelia africana, Anogeissus leiocarpa, Ceiba pentandra, Dialium guineense and Diospyros mespiliformis in a semi-deciduous vertisol forest in Southern Benin. Since the predictions of Yasso07 were not consistent with the observations on mass loss and chemical composition of litter, Yasso07 was fitted to the dataset composed of global data and the new experimental data from Benin. The re-parameterized versions of Yasso07 had a good predictive ability and refined the applicability of the model in Benin to estimate soil carbon stocks, its changes and CO2 emissions from heterotrophic respiration as main outputs of the model. The findings of this research support the hypothesis that the high variation of litter quality observed in the tropics is a major driver of the decomposition and needs to be accounted in the model parameterization.
Received: 08 Apr 2013 – Discussion started: 28 May 2013
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
G. H. S. Guendehou , J. Liski , M. Tuomi , M. Moudachirou , B. Sinsin , and R. Mäkipää
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
G. H. S. Guendehou , J. Liski , M. Tuomi , M. Moudachirou , B. Sinsin , and R. Mäkipää
G. H. S. Guendehou , J. Liski , M. Tuomi , M. Moudachirou , B. Sinsin , and R. Mäkipää
Viewed
Total article views: 2,874 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
2,176
579
119
2,874
106
134
HTML: 2,176
PDF: 579
XML: 119
Total: 2,874
BibTeX: 106
EndNote: 134
Views and downloads (calculated since 28 May 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
May 2013
25
21
4
50
Jun 2013
29
35
1
65
Jul 2013
12
22
1
35
Aug 2013
3
10
1
14
Sep 2013
8
21
1
30
Oct 2013
14
19
3
36
Nov 2013
9
14
4
27
Dec 2013
12
19
1
32
Jan 2014
14
21
4
39
Feb 2014
11
15
2
28
Mar 2014
7
15
0
22
Apr 2014
8
11
0
19
May 2014
6
5
0
11
Jun 2014
3
6
2
11
Jul 2014
5
11
1
17
Aug 2014
4
14
2
20
Sep 2014
7
11
0
18
Oct 2014
7
6
0
13
Nov 2014
2
12
0
14
Dec 2014
3
17
0
20
Jan 2015
3
5
0
8
Feb 2015
9
2
0
11
Mar 2015
20
2
0
22
Apr 2015
44
4
3
51
May 2015
31
0
31
Jun 2015
36
2
0
38
Jul 2015
41
3
0
44
Aug 2015
36
6
1
43
Sep 2015
35
3
0
38
Oct 2015
40
2
2
44
Nov 2015
49
4
0
53
Dec 2015
33
7
0
40
Jan 2016
42
6
1
49
Feb 2016
36
2
3
41
Mar 2016
38
4
0
42
Apr 2016
26
7
0
33
May 2016
27
5
0
32
Jun 2016
20
1
0
21
Jul 2016
22
3
1
26
Aug 2016
21
3
0
24
Sep 2016
20
2
0
22
Oct 2016
21
3
0
24
Nov 2016
18
2
0
20
Dec 2016
12
1
0
13
Jan 2017
30
2
0
32
Feb 2017
25
2
0
27
Mar 2017
43
4
4
51
Apr 2017
63
1
3
67
May 2017
57
5
2
64
Jun 2017
50
4
3
57
Jul 2017
38
2
1
41
Aug 2017
22
2
0
24
Sep 2017
5
1
0
6
Oct 2017
3
1
0
4
Nov 2017
7
0
7
Dec 2017
8
1
0
9
Jan 2018
14
1
0
15
Feb 2018
21
5
26
Mar 2018
8
4
3
15
Apr 2018
7
2
1
10
May 2018
11
4
1
16
Jun 2018
11
1
2
14
Jul 2018
12
3
1
16
Aug 2018
9
4
0
13
Sep 2018
14
4
0
18
Oct 2018
17
1
0
18
Nov 2018
24
3
0
27
Dec 2018
11
1
0
12
Jan 2019
13
2
0
15
Feb 2019
14
2
0
16
Mar 2019
10
2
0
12
Apr 2019
7
3
1
11
May 2019
7
1
0
8
Jun 2019
11
6
1
18
Jul 2019
16
3
0
19
Aug 2019
10
2
0
12
Sep 2019
4
1
5
Oct 2019
10
5
1
16
Nov 2019
17
0
17
Dec 2019
16
3
0
19
Jan 2020
26
1
0
27
Feb 2020
19
3
0
22
Mar 2020
11
1
0
12
Apr 2020
2
0
2
May 2020
5
1
6
Jun 2020
3
0
3
Jul 2020
8
6
5
19
Aug 2020
6
1
7
Sep 2020
14
2
0
16
Oct 2020
14
3
1
18
Nov 2020
9
2
1
12
Dec 2020
15
3
1
19
Jan 2021
18
3
0
21
Feb 2021
19
2
0
21
Mar 2021
18
0
18
Apr 2021
18
0
18
May 2021
11
3
0
14
Jun 2021
12
0
12
Jul 2021
9
0
9
Aug 2021
2
2
0
4
Sep 2021
1
1
0
2
Oct 2021
5
1
0
6
Nov 2021
14
5
0
19
Dec 2021
22
5
7
34
Jan 2022
13
2
1
16
Feb 2022
20
1
0
21
Mar 2022
8
3
1
12
Apr 2022
11
2
0
13
May 2022
4
3
0
7
Jun 2022
2
1
0
3
Jul 2022
14
0
14
Aug 2022
10
3
1
14
Sep 2022
16
1
0
17
Oct 2022
3
2
1
6
Nov 2022
9
1
0
10
Dec 2022
6
1
1
8
Jan 2023
11
1
0
12
Feb 2023
8
2
0
10
Mar 2023
22
1
1
24
Apr 2023
9
0
9
May 2023
6
7
3
16
Jun 2023
6
3
2
11
Jul 2023
6
3
0
9
Aug 2023
4
1
0
5
Sep 2023
9
2
1
12
Oct 2023
11
1
12
Nov 2023
5
1
1
7
Dec 2023
10
1
1
12
Jan 2024
7
3
1
11
Feb 2024
13
3
3
19
Mar 2024
7
4
2
13
Apr 2024
17
2
7
26
May 2024
8
2
4
14
Jun 2024
12
3
0
15
Jul 2024
20
4
2
26
Aug 2024
29
3
0
32
Sep 2024
21
1
0
22
Oct 2024
9
2
0
11
Nov 2024
15
1
0
16
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 28 May 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
May 2013
25
21
4
Jun 2013
54
56
5
Jul 2013
66
78
6
Aug 2013
69
88
7
Sep 2013
77
109
8
Oct 2013
91
128
11
Nov 2013
100
142
15
Dec 2013
112
161
16
Jan 2014
126
182
20
Feb 2014
137
197
22
Mar 2014
144
212
22
Apr 2014
152
223
22
May 2014
158
228
22
Jun 2014
161
234
24
Jul 2014
166
245
25
Aug 2014
170
259
27
Sep 2014
177
270
27
Oct 2014
184
276
27
Nov 2014
186
288
27
Dec 2014
189
305
27
Jan 2015
192
310
27
Feb 2015
201
312
27
Mar 2015
221
314
27
Apr 2015
265
318
30
May 2015
296
318
30
Jun 2015
332
320
30
Jul 2015
373
323
30
Aug 2015
409
329
31
Sep 2015
444
332
31
Oct 2015
484
334
33
Nov 2015
533
338
33
Dec 2015
566
345
33
Jan 2016
608
351
34
Feb 2016
644
353
37
Mar 2016
682
357
37
Apr 2016
708
364
37
May 2016
735
369
37
Jun 2016
755
370
37
Jul 2016
777
373
38
Aug 2016
798
376
38
Sep 2016
818
378
38
Oct 2016
839
381
38
Nov 2016
857
383
38
Dec 2016
869
384
38
Jan 2017
899
386
38
Feb 2017
924
388
38
Mar 2017
967
392
42
Apr 2017
1,030
393
45
May 2017
1,087
398
47
Jun 2017
1,137
402
50
Jul 2017
1,175
404
51
Aug 2017
1,197
406
51
Sep 2017
1,202
407
51
Oct 2017
1,205
408
51
Nov 2017
1,212
408
51
Dec 2017
1,220
409
51
Jan 2018
1,234
410
51
Feb 2018
1,255
410
56
Mar 2018
1,263
414
59
Apr 2018
1,270
416
60
May 2018
1,281
420
61
Jun 2018
1,292
421
63
Jul 2018
1,304
424
64
Aug 2018
1,313
428
64
Sep 2018
1,327
432
64
Oct 2018
1,344
433
64
Nov 2018
1,368
436
64
Dec 2018
1,379
437
64
Jan 2019
1,392
439
64
Feb 2019
1,406
441
64
Mar 2019
1,416
443
64
Apr 2019
1,423
446
65
May 2019
1,430
447
65
Jun 2019
1,441
453
66
Jul 2019
1,457
456
66
Aug 2019
1,467
458
66
Sep 2019
1,471
458
67
Oct 2019
1,481
463
68
Nov 2019
1,498
463
68
Dec 2019
1,514
466
68
Jan 2020
1,540
467
68
Feb 2020
1,559
470
68
Mar 2020
1,570
471
68
Apr 2020
1,572
471
68
May 2020
1,577
471
69
Jun 2020
1,580
471
69
Jul 2020
1,588
477
74
Aug 2020
1,594
477
75
Sep 2020
1,608
479
75
Oct 2020
1,622
482
76
Nov 2020
1,631
484
77
Dec 2020
1,646
487
78
Jan 2021
1,664
490
78
Feb 2021
1,683
492
78
Mar 2021
1,701
492
78
Apr 2021
1,719
492
78
May 2021
1,730
495
78
Jun 2021
1,742
495
78
Jul 2021
1,751
495
78
Aug 2021
1,753
497
78
Sep 2021
1,754
498
78
Oct 2021
1,759
499
78
Nov 2021
1,773
504
78
Dec 2021
1,795
509
85
Jan 2022
1,808
511
86
Feb 2022
1,828
512
86
Mar 2022
1,836
515
87
Apr 2022
1,847
517
87
May 2022
1,851
520
87
Jun 2022
1,853
521
87
Jul 2022
1,867
521
87
Aug 2022
1,877
524
88
Sep 2022
1,893
525
88
Oct 2022
1,896
527
89
Nov 2022
1,905
528
89
Dec 2022
1,911
529
90
Jan 2023
1,922
530
90
Feb 2023
1,930
532
90
Mar 2023
1,952
533
91
Apr 2023
1,961
533
91
May 2023
1,967
540
94
Jun 2023
1,973
543
96
Jul 2023
1,979
546
96
Aug 2023
1,983
547
96
Sep 2023
1,992
549
97
Oct 2023
2,003
549
98
Nov 2023
2,008
550
99
Dec 2023
2,018
551
100
Jan 2024
2,025
554
101
Feb 2024
2,038
557
104
Mar 2024
2,045
561
106
Apr 2024
2,062
563
113
May 2024
2,070
565
117
Jun 2024
2,082
568
117
Jul 2024
2,102
572
119
Aug 2024
2,131
575
119
Sep 2024
2,152
576
119
Oct 2024
2,161
578
119
Nov 2024
2,176
579
119
Cited
Saved
Latest update: 21 Nov 2024